Keeping You Connected

The RCMA keeps you up to date on the latest news,
policy developments, and events

News

Governance Reform: CMA envisions a new future for organized medicine



By Steven E. Larson, M.D., MPH, Chair of the CMA Governance Technical Advisory Committee

 

Change is never easy. But oftentimes is it necessary, and even invigorating. The California Medical Association (CMA) is about to embark on a journey of change that will position our association as a nimble, proactive organization ready to lead the practice of medicine into a brave new world. In 2013, the CMA House of Delegates (HOD) approved a plan to reform the way our association is governed. Will it be easy? No. Will it be worth it? There is not a doubt in my mind.

 

In a nutshell, the reforms will make CMA more relevant and effective by focusing the association on, and bolstering its resources to address, the critical issues of universal importance to physicians. By doing so, CMA will be better able to protect the interests of its physician members and, even more importantly, guide the future of our profession, not only in California but nationwide.

 

150 Years of Tradition

For 150 plus years, CMA has been guided by the HOD, which meets once a year to set policies and direct resource allocation. This has led to a sometimes unwieldy 581-member HOD, a Board of Trustees numbering more than 50, a seven-member Executive Committee and hundreds of other members serving as alternate delegates and in various capacities on dozens of councils, committees, sections and mode of practice forums.

 

Over the years, there have been several task forces assigned to this subject. It wasn't until this year, however, that the abstract discussions about "governance reform" began to produce concrete results.

 

These discussions resulted in big questions. Does the HOD foster a reactive culture rather than a proactive one? Does it inhibit CMA’s ability to take quick action in a rapidly evolving health care environment?

 

While these questions were being asked, the HOD was spending most of its time on a growing number of resolutions that struggled to be assigned or implemented because of resource limitations.

 

The CMA Board of Trustees, realizing that a floundering governing style prevented the organization from quickly acting on issues of universal import to the membership and their patients, created a committee—the Governance Technical Advisory Committee (GTAC)—to look at this issue.

 

The GTAC confirmed what the executive committee had feared —the association was unable to quickly address universal issues that arose faster than the once-a-year HOD meetings could handle. And, there were other inefficiencies in CMA’s governing bodies and processes.

 

And there was the cost. An independent study commissioned by CMA (an activity-based costing, or “ABC” study) found that CMA governance is far more resource-intensive than previously thought, accounting for almost one-third of CMA’s operating budget—an allocation that commensurately reduces resources available for advocacy and other member services.

 

The GTAC began its discussion of how to bring relevance, democracy and cost-effectiveness to governing the association. It became clear to us that the rank and file members want more advocacy, while the delegates and trustees are heavily invested in leadership.

 

Tackling the Big Issues

A proposal to reform CMA's governing structure, put before the 2013 CMA HOD by the GTAC this past October, proposed that instead of a diffuse focus on many issues, the HOD take on a limited number of big issues—the most important, most pressing matters facing physicians and the practice of medicine.

 

CMA’s long-standing traditions of democratic participation and representative governance would continue; the difference, as envisioned by the GTAC, is that specific issues that are of concern to a narrow spectrum of the membership would no longer command HOD’s limited time. Rather, the democratically elected Board of Trustees would act on those issues, as it already does on the increasing number of matters referred to the board for action by a House that is aware of its policy-making constraints.

 

The HOD would continue to set policy on major issues, and its decisions would be informed through a year-round process not constrained by 15-minute limits on debate of recommendations developed in a rushed overnight exercise, as is currently the case. More focused expertise would be brought to bear in a more careful development of recommendations for action. Policy on other issues would realize the same benefits of a more careful and expert deliberative process throughout the year.

 

We would like to improve the discussion at the House of Delegates to deal with the big issues of the day and to utilize the valuable resources of our delegates for the collective development and direction of important policy matters. We believe this proposal has real potential for a robust discussion around issues that will impact all physicians.

 

The reforms would also open the discussion to individual members who could continue to bring forth their ideas and proposals through a year-round resolution process provided for in the CMA bylaws. Such proposals would be studied, with recommendations acted on by the board.

 

A year-round dialog about timely issues should result in well-thought out policy pieces that could be brought to the floor during HOD.

 

Charting a Course for the Next 150 Years

This year’s discussion and debate at HOD on governance reform has set the stage for the GTAC to make proposals to modify the bylaws to begin the changes needed to set CMA’s course for the next 150 years.

 

I am optimistic that this will result in an improvement for our entire organization. It will make CMA more effective in reaching the average member and give them a direct voice in policy, bringing broader input into our more difficult decisions.

 

 

The full report of the CMA Governance Technical Advisory Committee, as amended by the House of Delegates at its October 2013 meeting in Anaheim, is available for download on the California Medical Association website. To access the report, available to members only, visit www.cmanet.org/hod and click on the "documents" tab. The report begins on page 12 of the "Actions of the 2013 House of Delegates" document.



Comments are closed.

Tags

2013 2014 Ebola Outbreak 2014 Election 2016 Abuse ACA Addiction AIDS All Physicians Annual Report Appointments Assembly Business and Professions Committee Awards Ballot Initiatives Boxer Budget Burnout CA Ballot Initiatives CAFP California CMA CMA Annual Report Comments Congress Construction Controlled Substance COVID-19 Discontent Dolores Early-Career Physician EHR Election Election 2014 Exchange Financial Governance Grace Period H.R.2. Health Exchange Health Laws Healthcare Laws HIE HIT HIV Hizon HOD House House of Delegates ICD-10 IEHP Languages Lee Legislation Mahdi Meaningful Use Medical Medi-Cal Medical Office Safety Medicare MICRA Mode of Practice New No on 46 NoOn46 Opioids Outstanding Contribution Palm Springs Patients Paul Green Physicians for a Healthy California Practice Management Prop 46 Prop 56 Proposition 46 Public Health Public Health Alert Public Safety Power Outage Rajaratnam Ranch Mirage Rancho Springs Rating RCMA RCMA President Repeal Residents Risk Management Riverside Community Hospital Riverside County Schedualing Senate SGR Shooting Southwest Healthcare Stage 2 Stress Termination Trial Lawyers Uppal Vaccines White Wilson Creek Winery #GivingTuesday #Medi-CalRedetermination #MeToo #RiversideCountyPhysicians 2014 2014 Election 2014 laws 2015-2017 2016 2016 Election 2018 2019 2020 2021 2021 taxes 2022 Employment Law 2023 Year in Review 46 AB 2770 AB 3087 AB 3109 AB 5 AB 880 AB5 ABMS ABX2-15 ACA Advisory Council Advocacy Affordable Care Act AHCA AMA Anthem Blue Cross Asian Violence Assembly Assembly Bill Attestation Awards Awards Committee Behavioral Health Benefit Big Tobacco Blue Shield of California board certification board certified Bruce Holmblad Burnout CA CA Senate Cal INDEX CalHealthCares Calhhs California California Employment Law California Laws California Legislation California Society of Plastic Surgeons Californian Physicians Call for Nominations Cameron Kaiser CCI CDC CEO certification Childcare City of Riverside Claims Clearinghouses CMA CME CMS Coalition for Patient Access and Quality Care Committee Confidential Congress Contributions to Medicine controlled substances Coronavirus Coronavirus Testing Coroner Council on Graduate Medical Education Covered CA Covered Califonria Covered California covid19 COVID-19 COVID-19 Employer Concerns COVID-19 Financial Assistance COVID-19 Resources COVID-19 Response COVID-19 Testing COVID-19 Updates COVID-19-Resources CPT modifer CSPS Cultural Diversity CURES Cuts Data Exchange data exchange framework data sharing data sharing agreement David Duffner Deadlines DEARequirements deductible Delegates Delivery Models Depression DHCS Documentation donate Donate to RCMA Donations Drugs Dual Elligibles DxF Ebola ehi EHR eligibility employee Employee Classification Employer Concerns Employer Guidance employment employment law Employment Status End-Of-Life Energy and Commerce Committee Republicans enrollment ERISA Ethnic Unity Exchange FAQ Federal Federal Legislation Feinstein Financial Assistance financial planning Free Free PPE Funding fundraiser Future Gary Honts GivingTuesday Governor Governor Newsom Grace Period Health Care Reform Health Information health information exchange Health Reform healthcare burnout Healthcare Information Technoloogy Healthcare Legislation Healthcare Rates Healthcare Reform healthcare symposium healthcare worker bonus Healthcare Workers Hernandez HIPAA HIT Holiday Giving ICD-10 IEFMC IEHIE IEHP IEPCC Imagine Plastic Surgery Increase infoblocking informationblocking informationblockingfaq informationblockingrule Installation Installation of Officers insurance investments JFK Memorial Hospital Jiangmen China Hospital Kaiser Permanente lactation accomodations Laws legal Legislation Legislative Alert Loan Assistance Loan repayment Loan Repayment Progam Loan Repayment Scholarship Program Loma Linda long term disability LTSS MA Mahdi Maintenance of Certification Managed Care Manifest MedEx marketing Meaningful Use Measles Med-CalRe-enrollment Medcare Medicaid Medi-Cal medical board Medical law medical practices medical staff Medical Student Scholarship Fund Medical Students Medical Supply Donations Medi-CalEligibility medicare medicare cuts 2023 member benefit Mental Health Mentoring MICRA minimum wage minimum wage increase MIPS MOC Molina Molina Healthcare NAACOS National Prescription Drug Take-Back Day News Nomination Nominations Nondiscrimination Posting Non-profit Donations norcal Noridian Obamacare Insurance October 22 On-Call ONET ONET Physicians opiod opiod advocacy opiod crisis opiod enforcement opiod epidemic opiods opioid opioid abuse Outstanding Outstanding Contributions Outstanding Contributions Awards Palmetto GBA Patient Patient Care Patient Data Patient Refusal of Treatment patients pay equity Paycheck protection Payment Models Pediatric Physicians PHA PHC Physician Physician Aid-in-Dying Physician Awards Physician Burnout physician certification physician medical board physician mentoring Physician mentors Physician Recruitment Physician Wellness Physicians Physicians for a healthy California Physicians in Riverside Pietro Wellness Fund Plastic Surgery POLST Population Health Power Outage PPE PPE Provider Survey PPE Supplies practice management practice managment Practice Mangement prescribing opiods prescription drugs President Priorities privacy ProAssurance Professional Liability Project K.I.N.D. Project Kind Prop 46 Prop 56 Proposition 46 Proposition 56 PSPS Public Health Public Health Alert Public Safety QPP Quality Payment Program RCH RCMA RCMA Business Partner RCMA Business Partners RCMA Docs RCMA Medicare Update RCMA Member RCMA Physicians RCMA Scholarship Program RCMA Stands RCMA Year In Review RCPMF Real-time Patient Data Red Tape Repayment Demands Reputation retention bonus retention payments Retreat Risk Management Riverside County Riverside County Medical Association riverside county physicians Riverside County Physicians Memorial Foundation Riverside County Public Health riverside physicians RiversideCountyMedicalAssociation RIVPAC RUHS RUHS-PH SB 1343 SB 491 SB 492 SB 493 SB 62 SB1343 SBA scholarship scholarship fundraiser Scholarships Scope of Practice Sequestration sexual harassment sexual harassment preventation sexual harassment training SGR Small Business Small Business Resources Small Businesses social media State Capitol Stress Survey taxes Telehealth Telemedicine Tenet Texting Safety Thakur Law Firm The Unforgettables Foundation Timothy Pietro Wellness Fund Toolkits Top Doctor Awards Transforming Your Practice UC Riverside UCR School of Medicine United Vaccines Management Vaccines Management Plan Value Based Care Vantage Virtual We Care for California Webinars Wellness WestPac Wealth Worker Classification Workers' Comp Workplace workplace compliance Year in Review Year-in-review

Current Initiatives

Medical Scholarship Programs

Scholarship Programs

Medical Student & Early-Career Physician Loan Repayment Programs

View Program
Member Benefits

Member Benefits

Resources that support our members’ practices.

Member Benefits
Physician Wellness

Physician Wellness

Supporting the health of physicians

Wellness Resources
Riverside County Medical Association Seal
California Medical Association Seal

Contact Us

Riverside County Medical Association (RCMA)
Mailing: PO Box 2425, Riverside, CA 92516
Location: 3993 Jurupa Ave., Riverside, CA 92506
Phone: (951) 686-3342
Email: membership@rcmadocs.org

As a member of the RCMA and/or its affiliated organizations (Inland Empire Foundation for Medical Care, Riverside County Foundation for Medical Care, Inland Empire Health Information Organization, Riverside County Physicians Memorial Foundation), I authorize Riverside County Medical Association, and its affiliated organizations listed above, permission to use my likeness, name and/or quote and consent to the audio and video recording of my voice, name, and image. I further consent to the distribution and broadcast of my appearance, including any information and content I provide, in audio, video, or text form for the purpose of publication, promotion, illustration, advertising, or any other related lawful purpose.